Thursday, May 5, 2011

Tops and Bottoms by Janet Stevens

Tops & Bottoms (Caldecott Honor Book)
Harcourt Brace & Company, San Diego, 1995.
Hardcover edition, 40 pages, ISBN 0-15-292851-0.

Stevens has created a freshly minted trickster tale a la Uncle Remus contrasting a hilariously lazy bear and an extremely enterprising hare. Hare has a large family to feed, but no land to grow a garden. Bear has all sorts of land, but no inclination to work. They enter into a sloppily defined pact crafted cleverly Hare, whereby Bear will receive the top half of all produce, and Hare will take the bottom half. Hare tricks Bear by planting all root vegetables such as radishes, carrots, and beets. When the sleepy Bear realizes he has been duped, he reverses the deal, but the cunning Hare plants lettuce, broccoli and celery. The angry Bear alters the contract so that he gets tops and bottoms while Hare gets only the middles. Hare slyly plants corn.

Bear learns from these episodes to become more attentive and industrious, while Hare profits by selling the vegetables to buy property to feed his family and perpetuate his business.

The story is best for the more mature end of the preschool spectrum, due to both the length and complexity of the text. The format of the book, which appropriately opens top to bottom, is perfect for group reading.

ABC Children's Booksellers' Choice
ALA Notable Children's Book
Bill Martin, Jr. Picture Book Award
Booklist Editors' Choice
Caldecott Honor Book
Colorado Children's Book Award
Instructor Magazine's Best Picture Book of the Twentieth Century
IRA Teachers' Choice
IRA-CBC Children's Choice
Maryland Children's Book Award
National Parenting Publications Gold Award
Parents' Choice Silver Honor Book
Show Me Readers Award
SSLI Honor Book
Storytelling World Award Honor Book

No comments:

Post a Comment